ROME, Italy / EuroWire.IO / – Italy’s data protection authority has fined Meta 805 million euros ($880 million) for accessing users’ photos without their specific consent, the regulator said on Saturday, November 14. The authority, known as the Garante, said the Facebook application for Android devices accessed photographs, videos and related metadata belonging to Italian users without obtaining specific consent and without properly informing them. Meta said it would appeal.

The decision concerns a Facebook feature called “Get tips from your gallery while browsing Facebook”, which has been available since 2023 and suggests photos from users’ phones for posting. The fine was imposed on Meta Platforms Ireland, the company’s European subsidiary. About 20 million people in Italy use Facebook on Android devices, the Garante said. It added that the infringement was continuing for users who had not updated the app.
The Garante based its ruling on Article 122 of Italy’s Privacy Code, which implements the EU’s ePrivacy Directive, rather than on the General Data Protection Regulation. The rule requires consent before information stored on a user’s device is accessed. Under the rule, consent is needed even if no content is uploaded. The penalty is equal to about 0.47% of Meta’s worldwide turnover, according to reports on the decision. The Garante is Italy’s independent privacy watchdog.
Meta to appeal “disproportionate” fine
Meta said it would challenge the decision. A company spokesperson said “we strongly disagree” with the regulator’s assessment “and the disproportionate level of the fine”. Meta said the feature only works after users grant permission on their devices, which they can change at any time. The company also denied using gallery content to train artificial intelligence models. The Garante’s investigation did not examine that question.
The regulator gave Meta 60 days to make the feature switched off by default and to request separate, specific consent from users. If the company misses the deadline, the feature cannot be activated for anyone who has not given valid consent. Meta can contest the fine before Italian courts. The decision applies to users in Italy. Users can also review app permissions in their phone settings.
Regulators tighten scrutiny of tech firms
European regulators have stepped up scrutiny of large technology platforms. In February, the European Commission ordered TikTok to change its addictive design under the Digital Services Act. Meta has faced several large privacy penalties in the EU, including a record €1.2 billion fine from Ireland’s Data Protection Commission in 2023 over data transfers to the United States. The Garante also temporarily blocked ChatGPT in 2023 and later fined OpenAI €15 million.
Data protection has become a growing concern across Europe as more personal information is stored on mobile devices. In Denmark, authorities expanded a probe after 8.8 million records were exposed in the country’s CPR personal registration system. Privacy regulators say users must be clearly informed before apps access their files. Meta, which also owns Instagram and WhatsApp, is based in Menlo Park, California. The decision covers only Italy, but other EU regulators apply the same ePrivacy rules.
